Merchant Payment Processing
Regulated environments where trust, compliance, and operational resilience are non-negotiable.
Inside this journey
-
Pre-Discovery
Align the room on outcomes, decision process, and constraints before deeper discovery.
-
Stakeholder Alignment
Confirm decision roles, timeline, pricing sensitivities, and success criteria across finance, e‑commerce, IT, and procurement.
Alignment Questions
Quick introductions — Who’s in the room?
- Which people or roles from your company are involved in this payments initiative today? (Select all that apply)
- Who will be the primary day‑to‑day point of contact for integration work and decisions?
- How confident are you that the right stakeholders are currently engaged for timely decisions?
- Please map the key decision types (pricing, technical, legal, go/no‑go) to the teams or people who must sign off.
- Do you already have a RACI, decision matrix, or governance doc we can review?
Who's really steering the ship?
- If this payments project failed, whose performance review or P&L would feel the biggest impact?
- Which stakeholder currently has veto power or final say on vendor/processor selection?
- Across finance, e‑commerce, IT, and procurement, which outcomes do each team prioritize most right now? (Select all that apply)
- Tell us about a past cross‑functional decision that either accelerated or stalled payments projects here—what happened and why?
- How long does executive sign‑off usually take for contracts of this kind in your organization?
Money talks — how much does cost steer the bus?
- If faced with a tradeoff between a 5% reduction in fees and a 1% drop in approvals, which direction is your leadership more likely to take?
- Which pricing model best describes your current arrangement?
- Roughly what share of your card volume is domestic versus cross‑border?
- How sensitive is finance to month‑to‑month variability in processing costs (e.g., spikes in interchange, currency FX)?
- Describe a recent month where payment costs materially impacted your margins or decisions—what caused it and what was the business impact?
- Are there pricing or banking constraints we must honor (preferred acquirers, interchange programs, or contracted rates)?
Timeline pressure — are deadlines helping or hurting?
- If your planned go‑live slips one quarter, what is at stake: revenue, campaigns, regulatory deadlines, or internal credibility?
- What is your target go‑live date and what is driving that date?
- Which internal milestones must be completed before integration can begin (select all that apply)?
- How reliably have previous integrations here met their planned timelines?
- If time becomes the constraint, which trade‑offs would your teams accept: reduced feature set at launch, phased rollout, or extended testing?
- Who on your team owns contingency and rollback plans for a payments cutover?
What would make every team breathe easier?
- If you could ask your payments partner for one guarantee that would ease internal tension, what would it be?
- Which KPIs will finance use to judge success after launch? (Select all that apply)
- Which metrics matter most to e‑commerce for customer experience evaluation? (Select all that apply)
- For IT/Engineering, what acceptance criteria will determine if the integration is ready (choose all that apply)?
- How will procurement or legal judge vendor performance beyond price (examples: SLAs, indemnities, data residency)?
- Imagine three months post‑launch—what dashboard metrics or business signals would prove this was the right decision?
Hidden risks and compliance headaches
- What single regulatory, compliance, or security concern about payments keeps you awake at night?
- How is PCI scope currently managed in your setup?
- Do you have complex settlement or reconciliation requirements we should know about (marketplace splits, multi‑currency settlements, platform payouts)?
- What fraud trends are you seeing (chargebacks, friendly fraud, bot attacks)? Please quantify or describe recent patterns.
- Which regulatory frameworks must we explicitly support for your business (select all that apply)?
- Who currently handles incident response and fraud investigations, and how long do typical investigations take?
Decision confidence — what will make you say yes?
- What would make you ready to sign this week instead of asking for more time?
- Which evaluation artifacts would most accelerate your approval (select all that apply)?
- Who must be included in the next meeting to keep momentum and avoid rework? (Select all that apply)
- What remaining questions or demos would shorten your internal approval cycle most effectively?
- If all criteria are met, when would you realistically be prepared to sign an agreement?
- Would you like us to draft a one‑page mutual commit checklist (stakeholders, timeline, KPIs, pricing) to align approvals?
-
Current State Mapping
Document existing payment flows, processors, tokenization, authorization/fraud performance, and integration touchpoints.
Current State
Getting Comfortable with Where You Are
- To start lightly: who on your team owns payments day-to-day, and how do they prefer to work with vendors?
- What is your current average monthly processed volume (USD)?
- Which payment types do you actively accept today?
- Describe in a sentence the single biggest thing you wish were different about your payments today.
- How would you rate your confidence that your current payment setup is scalable for the next 12–24 months?
Is Your Payments Architecture Actually Helping You?
- If your authorization rate could improve by 1–3 percentage points overnight, how much would that change your business?
- Which processor(s) or gateway(s) are you routing transactions through today? List all that apply and any regional specifics.
- How do you currently decide which processor or route a given transaction takes?
- What are your current authorization approval and decline patterns by channel (online, in-store, mobile)?
- How often do you review routing performance and make changes?
Where Money Gets Held Up and Why It Hurts
- When settlements miss expectations, who feels the pain first and what does that look like?
- What is your typical settlement cadence and how predictable is the timing?
- Have you experienced unexplained holds, reserves, or funding delays in the past 12 months? Tell us what happened and the impact.
- Which reconciliation tools or workflows do you use to match settlements to orders?
- How much time does your team spend each month resolving settlement discrepancies (estimate hours)?
The Fraud and Authorization Story No One Likes to Tell
- What would you say is more costly for you today: false declines that lose customers or fraud that costs money and reputation?
- Describe the fraud detection stack you use today (in-house rules, third-party provider, network services, manual review).
- What are your current monthly metrics for authorization rate, chargeback rate, and suspected fraud cases (approximate percentages or counts)?
- How do you balance friction and conversion—what percentage of orders do you subject to manual review or additional verification?
- When a suspicious transaction occurs, what is your escalation path and average resolution time?
How Tokenization and PCI Feel in Practice
- If PCI scope is creating hidden work for your team, what tasks keep coming back into your inbox?
- Which tokenization approach are you using for card-on-file and recurring billing?
- How confident are you that your current tokenization prevents card data exposure across all channels?
- Do you have PCI attestations or audits you must meet (e.g., SAQ A, A‑EP, D)? If yes, which ones and how recent?
- Tell us about any recent security incidents, breaches, or close calls related to payments and what changed afterward.
Who's Touching Your Payments Stack?
- If we traced a transaction from customer click to settlement, which internal teams or external vendors would we see involved?
- Which integration methods do you currently use across channels?
- How frequently does your engineering team make changes to payment integration (rate of deploys/updates)?
- Are there manual handoffs or shadow systems (spreadsheets, emails) that regularly intervene in payment operations?
- Who are your current external partners for payments (acquirers, PSPs, fraud vendors, banks)? Please name and indicate primary responsibility.
What’s Breaking the Rules — Unexpected Costs and Limits
- Which hidden or variable fees surprise you most on reconciled statements?
- Do you currently monitor and attribute cost-per-transaction by BIN, processor, or region?
- Have pricing surprises or fee disputes ever caused you to switch providers? What drove that decision?
- What limits—transaction amounts, volume caps, or geographic restrictions—have constrained your growth or product features?
- How important is transparent, itemized billing when evaluating a payments partner?
If We Could Snap Our Fingers—What Would You Change?
- Imagine one change to your payments stack that would reduce headaches overnight—what is it and why does it matter?
- Which outcomes would convince you to pursue a new payments approach in the next 90 days?
- How would a better payments experience change how your customers feel and behave (conversion, loyalty, AOV)?
- What internal approvals or signals would need to align for you to change processors or routing logic?
- If we proposed a test to improve a single metric (e.g., authorization rate), what minimum lift would make the test worthwhile for you?
Signals, Timeline, and Practical Next Steps
- What timeframe are you targeting to make a decision about payments changes?
- Who else should be part of our next conversation to move this forward, and what concerns will they raise?
- What would a successful discovery project look like in 30 days—what deliverables or answers do you want?
- Are there hard constraints we should know now (contractual obligations, exclusivity, sensitive markets)? Please describe.
- Finally, what’s the best way for our technical team to access a sandbox or sample data so we can validate assumptions?
-
-
Outcome Discovery
Define target metrics (authorization rate, chargebacks, settlement timing, cost per transaction) and must‑have capabilities for growth and compliance.
Discovery Questions
Start Here — Who are you representing today?
- Which role are you answering for in this conversation?
- How would you describe your company size and scale right now?
- Roughly how much do you process monthly (USD)? If ranges are easier, pick one.
- Which channels do you accept payments through today?
- Who currently owns payments internally and how does that feel day-to-day?
If This Keeps Going, What Breaks First?
- If your authorization rate stayed flat over the next 12 months, what would that cost you in lost orders or revenue?
- Which channel or geography shows the worst authorization performance today?
- Tell us about a recent incident where payment performance directly impacted a campaign, launch, or peak day—what happened and what did you lose?
- How often do you see unexplained authorization drops or intermittent processor issues?
- Which current payment partners or processors are in scope for these issues?
What’s the Real Cost — Beyond Fees
- If improving authorization by 1% required a 5–10% increase in per-transaction fees, would you consider it?
- What’s your current blended cost per transaction (all-in)? If unknown, give a range or estimate.
- How do payment costs flow into your P&L—are they a direct line-item, absorbed into COGS, or allocated elsewhere?
- Describe how a small improvement in authorization or settlement speed would impact your unit economics or customer LTV.
- Which metric would you prioritize if you could only improve one in the next 90 days?
Chargebacks, Fraud, and the Human Cost
- What would it look like if chargebacks dropped by half for your business—how would your team and finances change?
- What is your current chargeback rate (percentage) or range?
- Which dispute reasons are most common for you (fraudulent card, product not received, billing error, friendly fraud, other)?
- How much internal time (FTE hours/week) does chargeback and dispute handling currently consume?
- What has been your most painful fraud or chargeback story—and what kept it from being resolved faster?
Capabilities That Must Never Fail
- Which single capability failing on go-live would be catastrophic for your business?
- Which of the following capabilities are must-haves for your next payments partner?
- Are there regulatory, compliance, or certification requirements we must support (PCI scope, PSD2, 3DS, local licensing)? Please list.
- Which internal teams must have zero-loss of functionality during migration (e.g., subscriptions, POS, ERP reconciliation)?
- Describe any legacy integrations, middleware, or custom logic that are non-negotiable to preserve.
If Everything Went Perfectly Tomorrow
- Imagine day-one after launch went perfectly—what three measurable things would you point to as proof?
- What is your target authorization rate (%) by channel (online, mobile, in-store)? Please provide numbers if you have them.
- What settlement timing do you need to achieve your cash-flow goals?
- What is an acceptable target for cost per transaction (all-in) to consider this project successful?
- Which KPIs and cadence would you require in the first 90 days to feel confident (e.g., daily auth rate dashboard, weekly reconciliation, monthly executive summary)?
Decision Pressure and Timing — Who Holds the Keys?
- If this project were delayed by a quarter, what internal consequences would you face?
- Who are the decision-makers and approvers required to finalize pricing, SLA, and go/no-go? List names, roles, and their top concern.
- What is your preferred procurement model for pricing (interchange-plus, flat rate, hybrid)?
- What compliance or legal sign-offs are required before launch and who coordinates them?
- What timeline would you like to target from agreement to first live transactions?
Proof, Tests, and the Cutover Game Plan
- What live test scenarios would make you comfortable to cut over (e.g., high-volume batch, PSP failover, cross-border settlement, chargeback simulation)?
- Which acceptance thresholds must be met during testing for you to sign off (give specific numbers when possible)?
- How do you want to see evidence—dashboards, raw logs, reconciliation files, 3rd party attestation?
- What rollback or contingency conditions would trigger an immediate cutback and who has authority to call it?
- After launch, what ongoing support model would feel right—hands-on NOC support, weekly reviews, or a scheduled tune-up cadence?
Final Reflection — What Would Make This a No‑Brainer?
- If you could hand us three non-negotiable promises to earn your trust, what would they be (specific, measurable)?
- What reservations or hidden risks do you still feel when thinking about switching or changing payments partners?
- Who else should we talk to internally to surface the remaining objections or technical constraints?
- Would you be open to a short working session where we model ROI using your real numbers?
- Any final thoughts, must-know context, or red-lines we should keep in mind as we design your future state?
-
Solution Experience
Translate the customer’s goals into a concrete future state and walk through real scenarios that validate authorization, fraud, settlement, and UX outcomes.
Experience Meetings
- Current State & Impact Alignment
- Authorization & Fraud Scenario Walkthrough
- Settlement, Reconciliation & Dispute Scenarios
- Future-State Validation, Acceptance Criteria & Sign-Off
- Schedule final pre-scope review (Solution Scope) once remediation is complete.
- Customer & host to agree on a fraud-rule tuning plan with timing and rollback thresholds.
- Document any conditional rules or exclusions that must remain (e.g., high-risk SKUs, blocked countries).
- Session Setup & Acceptance Criteria Reminder
- Prove settlement and funding timelines meet the customer’s operational needs.
- Confirm reconciliation automations map correctly to the customer’s accounting structure.
- Verify dispute lifecycle and SLA commitments meet the customer's risk tolerance.
- Identify any exceptions that require manual processes and assign owners.
- Finance owner to provide GL mapping and bank statement samples for final reconciliation test.
- Operations to schedule a test settlement run in sandbox and deliver a reconciliation report.
- Agree escalation path and SLA penalties/credits for dispute resolution.
- Readout of Scenario Results
- Obtain mutual agreement on the defined future state in operational terms.
- Finalize and sign the acceptance checklist with explicit KPI thresholds and owners.
- Document remediation plan for any gaps with owners and deadlines.
- Confirm timeline to move the validated solution into Solution Scope and Mutual Commit stages.
- Publish the signed acceptance checklist and future-state sentence to the project workspace.
- Host to deliver a remediation plan with owners and dates for any outstanding gaps.
- Welcome & Objectives
- Produce and agree the crystal-clear one-sentence current state.
- Explicitly quantify the business consequences tied to each problem area.
- Set 3–5 measurable target KPIs that define the future state.
- Confirm the scenarios and technical/data prerequisites for scenario validation sessions.
- Update and publish the validated one-sentence current state and consequence summary to the shared workspace.
- Customer to deliver anonymized sample transaction payloads and authorization logs for selected scenarios.
- Define primary KPI owners and who will sign the acceptance criteria.
- Framing & Problem Reminder
- Demonstrate measurable authorization rate improvement for selected scenarios.
- Prove fraud tuning reduces false positives while keeping chargebacks within target.
- Capture required rule adjustments and any constraints (card network rules, BIN limitations).
- Obtain explicit customer validation that outcomes match their expectations or list exact gaps.
- Engineering to run a full test batch for the validated scenarios and share outcome report showing delta vs baseline.
- One-Sentence Current State Recap
- Settlement Timing Scenario
- Gap Analysis
- Scenario Selection & Success Criteria
- Scenario A — Authorization Recovery
- Reconciliation Use-Case
- Finalize One-Sentence Future State & KPIs
- Consequence Quantification
- Define Go/No-Go & Acceptance Checklist
- Stakeholder Impact & Risk
- Scenario B — Fraud False-Positive Reduction
- Chargeback & Dispute Flow Validation
- Define Target KPIs / Future-State Outcomes
- Reporting & Exception Handling
- Outcome Measurement & Side-Effects
- Next Steps & Ownership
- Validation & Agreement
- Confirm Scenarios & Data for Validation
-
Solution Scope
Define integration boundaries, modules (gateway, tokenization, fraud, routing, settlement), responsibilities, and acceptance criteria.
Scope Configuration
- Enable card acceptance (credit and debit)
- Integrate digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay)
- Activate ACH and bank transfer processing
- Configure authorization routing and failover
- Deploy PCI-compliant tokenization
- Enable fraud detection and custom rule sets
- Deploy chargeback management and representments
- Provision merchant dashboard and consolidated reporting
- Integrate Payments API and client SDKs
- Configure recurring and subscription billing
- Enable multi-currency processing and FX settlement
- Implement marketplace split settlements and payouts
- Integrate in-store POS terminals and hardware
Scope Questions
Enable card acceptance (credit and debit)
- Which card brands do you want to accept?
- Which sales channels will accept cards?
- What is your expected monthly card transaction volume (number of transactions)?
- What is your average order value (AOV)?
- Do you require level 2/3 data support for corporate/B2B transactions?
- Are there specific BIN-blocking or surcharge requirements for card acceptance?
Integrate digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay)
- Which digital wallets do you want to enable?
- Will wallet payments be supported in web, native mobile apps, or both?
- Do you need tokenization or device-check integration for wallet acceptance?
- Do you require localized wallet experiences for specific regions/countries?
- Are there UI/UX constraints (checkout redesign) we should plan for?
- If anything not listed above, describe special wallet integration needs or constraints.
Activate ACH and bank transfer processing
- Do you want ACH debits, ACH credits (payouts), or both?
- What volume and AOV do you expect for bank transfers compared to card transactions?
- Do you need same-day or next-day ACH settlement options?
- Will you require micro-deposit or instant account verification (Plaid/other)?
- Are there regulatory or bank-specific requirements for ACH in your region?
- Describe any reconciliation or reporting requirements specific to bank transfers.
Configure authorization routing and failover
- Do you currently use multiple acquirers or processors?
- What are your primary goals for routing (maximize approvals, lower cost, regional routing)?
- Do you need per-card-product routing rules (e.g., Amex to specific acquirer)?
- What failover behavior do you prefer if a primary route is down?
- Are there chargeback/settlement implications for routing decisions we should know about?
- Provide any SLAs or latency targets for authorizations (e.g., <300ms).
Deploy PCI-compliant tokenization
- Which tokenization model do you prefer?
- Will you require tokens for card-on-file, recurring billing, or one-time transactions?
- Do you need PCI SAQ reduction or full PCI scope elimination assistance?
- Are there specific encryption/HSM or key management requirements?
- Do you require token migration/rotation policies and timelines?
- Describe any existing vault or token store we must integrate with.
Enable fraud detection and custom rule sets
- Do you currently use a fraud provider or in-house rules engine?
- What fraud outcomes are highest priority (false declines, chargeback reduction, velocity controls)?
- Do you want prebuilt scoring models, or fully custom rule sets (or both)?
- What tolerance do you have for manual review (percentage of transactions routed to review)?
- Will you need device fingerprinting, 3DS2, or behavioral analytics?
- Provide any industry-specific fraud patterns we should prioritize (e.g., gift cards, subscriptions).
Deploy chargeback management and representments
- What is your current monthly chargeback rate and target rate?
- Do you want automated chargeback alerts and dispute filing, or manual workflows?
- Do you have internal evidence templates (invoices, proof of delivery) to attach to representments?
- Are there specific timelines or SLA requirements for dispute responses?
- Do you need reporting on chargeback reason codes and root-cause analysis?
- Describe any current integrations or tools used for dispute management.
Provision merchant dashboard and consolidated reporting
- Who are the primary dashboard users (roles)?
- Which KPIs must be available out-of-the-box?
- Do you require custom or scheduled reports (daily/weekly/monthly)?
- Do you need role-based access controls and audit logs in the dashboard?
- Do you require integration with external BI tools or data warehouses?
- List any specific reconciliation or GL mapping requirements for reporting.
Integrate Payments API and client SDKs
- Which integration approach do you plan to use?
- Which platforms/languages must SDKs support (web, iOS, Android, backend language)?
- Do you need PCI SAQ reduction via client-side tokenization or hosted fields?
- What is your expected developer timeline and availability for integration work?
- Do you require example code, SDK customization, or white-labeling of UI components?
- Are there specific security requirements for API keys, IP allowlists, or OAuth?
Configure recurring and subscription billing
- What billing models do you use or plan to use?
- Do you need proration, trial periods, and automated dunning workflows?
- How many active subscription plans and SKUs do you anticipate?
- Do you require customer self-serve portals to manage subscriptions?
- What billing currencies and taxes must be supported for subscriptions?
- Describe expected churn rates and recovery targets for failed payments.
-
Mutual Commit
Finalize pricing model, SLAs, compliance responsibilities, timelines, and go/no‑go conditions.
Agreement Modules
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Master Services Agreement (MSA)
- Pricing & Fee Schedule
- Service Level Agreement (SLA)
- Data Processing Agreement (DPA) & Compliance
- Implementation Timeline & Milestones
- Acceptance Criteria & Go/No‑Go Conditions
- Integration & Third‑Party Connectors Annex
- Security & Incident Response Plan
- Billing, Settlement & Funding Terms
- Change Order & Scope Management
- Termination, Exit & Data Return Plan
- Operational Contacts & Escalation Matrix
- Regulatory, Underwriting & KYC Acceptance
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Verify environments, test data, access, PCI scope, routing rules, and rollback/contingency plans prior to launch.
Readiness Questions
A Quick Snapshot — Tell Us Who You Really Are
- What is your role and day-to-day responsibility for payments?
- Which of these best describes your business model today?
- What is your current monthly processed volume (USD)?
- Which sales channels do you operate in today? (Select all that apply.)
- If you had to name the single biggest reason you’re exploring payment changes right now, what would it be?
Are You Quietly Leaving Revenue on the Table?
- How often do you feel an authorization that should have approved is declined or routed poorly?
- Roughly what percentage of your attempted transactions are declined or fail to complete?
- When a payment fails, what do you typically see customers do next? (Select all that apply.)
- Can you share a recent example where a payment decline directly affected an order, promotion, or customer relationship?
- If we could increase your authorization approvals by 1–3 percentage points tomorrow, what would that mean to your monthly revenue or customer experience?
Where the Costs and Headaches Hide
- What’s the single cost or loss from payments that nags at you most—fees, chargebacks, fraud, delays, or something else?
- What is your current annualized chargeback or disputes rate (percentage of gross volume)?
- How much do payment-related operational tasks (reconciliation, disputes, refunds) pull time from your team each week?
- Which fraud types cause the most trouble for you right now?
- Tell us about a recent fraud or reconciliation problem—what happened, how long it took to resolve, and how it felt for your team and customers?
How Fragile Is Your Checkout Right Now?
- If your primary payment integration failed for a day, how much business would you lose?
- Which of these best describes how payments are integrated into your stack?
- Do you currently tokenize card data and is tokenization used across channels?
- Which systems must integrate with payments for you to launch (select all that apply)?
- How confident is your engineering team in delivering a new payment integration within your target timeline?
- Describe any past integrations that overran schedule or caused customer friction—what were the root causes?
If Payments Were a Superpower for Your Business
- Imagine payments were flawless—what key business outcome would change first (revenue, retention, margins, expansion)?
- Which three KPI targets would feel like a clear win for you in the first 90 days? (Pick up to 3.)
- What specific customer experience changes would you want to see (fewer failed carts, faster refunds, smoother wallet flows)?
- Are you planning geographic or channel expansion in the next 12–24 months? If so, where and why?
- What would need to be demonstrably different to make you recommend your payments setup internally to leadership?
Who’s Actually Making the Call — And How They’ll Decide
- If this project stalls, what’s usually the reason—budget, risk, IT capacity, or competing priorities?
- Which stakeholders must sign off before procurement (select all that apply)?
- How long is your typical purchasing / approval cycle for platform or vendor changes?
- What are the non‑negotiable procurement requirements we should know about (e.g., SOC2, PCI evidence, SLAs, insurance)?
- Who will be your internal champion for this project and how will they measure success internally?
What Could Threaten Launch — Let’s Find It Now
- What single failure scenario at launch would create the most damage for your business?
- Do you have a documented rollback or contingency plan for payments releases?
- Which monitoring and alerting tools will you use to detect payment issues post‑launch?
- Who on your team will be on call during cutover and in the 72 hours after launch?
- What kinds of test data and sandbox scenarios do you require before go‑live (e.g., refunds, partial captures, 3DS flows, multi‑currency)?
- Are there any compliance or PCI tasks that must be completed before we can begin end‑to‑end testing?
A Small Win Today — What Would Make You Say Yes?
- What are the must‑have features or guarantees you need to greenlight a pilot or first phase?
- How long of a pilot would prove value for you (and what sample size is meaningful)?
- Which commercial models would you consider (select all that apply)?
- What support and enablement do you need to feel confident (engineering handoffs, runbook, weekly ops calls, training)?
- If we left this conversation with one clear next step, what would you want it to be?
-
Deployment Enablement
Schedule tasks, assign engineering and operations owners, coordinate cutover steps, and activate monitoring and escalation paths.
-
Validation Checklist
Run live acceptance tests for payments, settlement reconciliation, fraud tuning, and document results against KPIs.
Validation Questions
Start Here: Tell Us About Your Payments World
- In one sentence, describe your business and the role you play in payments decisions.
- Which sales channels do you currently accept payments through?
- Roughly how many transactions do you process per month?
- Which payment methods do you prioritize today?
- Who typically makes the final decision on a payments provider at your company?
- How urgent is improving your payments experience and operations right now?
Are You Settling for 'Good Enough'?
- If you had to admit it, where are you tolerating mediocre payment performance because 'it’s complicated'?
- Which of these areas do you feel is currently underperforming most?
- How do you currently measure authorization performance, and what feels missing from that measurement?
- How often do you find yourself accepting a workaround (manual process, refunds, extra staff) to compensate for payments issues?
- When payment problems recur, how does that affect your confidence in growth plans or vendor relationships?
The Money That Slips Through the Cracks
- How much are you quietly losing to fees, declines, chargebacks, and fraud each month?
- Which cost categories impact your margins the most?
- Do you track a blended processing rate or cost per transaction today?
- What percentage of card declines do you estimate are recoverable through retrying or smarter routing?
- If you could reduce effective processing costs by 10%, what specific investments or outcomes would that fund?
When Payments Fail — What's It Really Like?
- When a payment failure happens at peak traffic, what breaks next — and who ends up paying the bill?
- How often do you experience severe incidents (outages, cascading declines, reconciliation gaps)?
- Tell the story of the single most damaging payments incident you can recall and its business impact (revenue, churn, reputation).
- How are customer-facing issues (failed charges, duplicate charges, refunds) triaged and communicated today?
- What monitoring or alerting do you have that would catch a critical payments problem before customers complain?
What Would Success Look Like — Not in Hype, But in Metrics
- If you could measure one metric that proves payments are 'fixed', which one would it be?
- Which set of KPIs do you need on day‑to‑day vs. executive dashboards?
- For your top three KPIs, please state current numbers and realistic targets (e.g., auth 92% → 96%).
- How frequently do you need KPI updates to feel confident making decisions?
- Who in your organization must have immediate access to these KPI reports?
If Payments Were No Longer a Bottleneck, What's Possible?
- What's the first new revenue stream, market, or experiment you'd launch if payments just worked flawlessly?
- Which growth scenarios matter most to you in the next 12–24 months?
- What integration or product risk could most derail those growth plans?
- Do you require multi‑currency settlement or local acquiring in target markets?
- How quickly would you want to pilot a new channel once payments are integrated?
Who Really Holds the Keys?
- Who in your organization can say 'no' to this payments project — and why might they?
- Which stakeholders must sign off for go‑live? (select all that apply)
- For each stakeholder above, what is their primary concern or success criteria?
- Have you engaged your security or compliance teams about PCI, data residency, or local regulations?
- What procurement or contractual requirements tend to slow decisions (e.g., indemnity, SOC2, audit windows, SLAs)?
Integration: How Deep Are We Digging?
- Are you willing to accept the integration complexity required to get the specific outcomes you want?
- Which integration model do you prefer for checkout and payments?
- What existing systems must the payment platform connect to?
- What is your engineering tech stack and preferred SDKs?
- What integration constraints should we plan for (FTEs available, blackout windows, peak season)?
Risk, Compliance, and Reconciliation Reality
- If reconciliation is a mess, how long does it take to find and fix a settlement mismatch today?
- How do you reconcile settlements and fees now?
- Which compliance frameworks or regional regulations impact your payments (select all that apply)?
- Who owns chargeback disputes and what is your current dispute win rate?
- How confident are you in your fraud detection tuning and false positive rate?
What's the Smallest Step That Proves This Is Working?
- What is the smallest, measurable pilot outcome that would convince you to expand (be specific)?
- Which pilot success criteria would you require to call it a win? (choose top items)
- What environments, test data, and accounts do we need access to for live acceptance testing?
- What is your preferred governance for go/no‑go (single exec sign‑off, cross‑functional sign‑off, automated health checks)?
- Who will be on‑call during deployment and what channels should we use for escalations?
Practical Next Steps: Commitments, Timelines, and Quick Wins
- Given everything we've covered, what timeline feels realistic for a pilot and for full rollout?
- What are your top three non‑negotiables for any provider agreement (e.g., SLA, pricing transparency, data access)?
- What internal approvals or contracts must be completed before a pilot can start?
- What would be the best way for us to demonstrate early value — a technical spike, a fee analysis, or a small live pilot?
- When should we schedule a follow‑up to review this discovery and align on next steps?
-
-
Success
Review outcomes against agreed KPIs, capture learnings, and maintain a shared channel for issues and product improvements.
Success Reviews
- KPI Review & Outcomes
- Post-Deployment Retrospective (Lessons Learned)
- Customer Success Check-in (Merchant Facing)
- Product Improvement & Roadmap Prioritization
- Operational Runbook & Escalation Review
Issues & Enhancements
- Engineering to produce high-level estimates and identify any blocking dependencies within 7 business days.
- Capture prioritized merchant requests and assign owners with timelines.
- Establish and confirm the shared communication channel and escalation SLAs for ongoing issues.
- Set up the agreed shared channel (Slack/Teams workspace or dedicated email thread) and invite merchant and internal stakeholders.
- Log merchant-submitted improvement requests into the product backlog with merchant-priority tags.
- Schedule recurring customer success check-ins at the agreed cadence and include KPI snapshots on the agenda.
- Context & Request Inventory
- Produce a prioritized list of product and operational improvements committed for the next release cycle.
- Define experiments/MVPs for high-impact items with clear success metrics and owners.
- Ensure merchant-facing expectations are aligned to roadmap timelines.
- PM to create prioritized roadmap entries and link required technical tickets with owners and target release windows.
- Introductions & Objectives
- Product to propose an A/B experiment plan for at least one high-impact change to validate benefit before full rollout.
- Incident History & Patterns
- Finalize and publish runbooks and rollback procedures for the top operational risks.
- Ensure monitoring alerts map to clear owners and result in predictable triage/escalation behavior.
- Confirm SLAs and merchant notification expectations for incident handling.
- Operations to publish runbooks and rollback checklists to the shared knowledge base with versioning and owners.
- SRE/Monitoring to implement adjusted alert thresholds and add suppression rules to reduce noise within 3 business days.
- Schedule a tabletop incident simulation with SRE, Ops, Support, and Merchant Success within 2 weeks to validate runbooks.
- Confirm which KPIs are on target and which require intervention.
- Agree on concrete, owner-assigned actions to close KPI gaps with success criteria and deadlines.
- Identify any immediate operational risks that require escalation.
- Owner to deliver a 30-day remediation plan for each KPI below target, including success metrics and resources required.
- Analytics team to provide a segmented export (by channel, BIN, region) to validate root-cause hypotheses within 5 business days.
- Schedule a 2-week checkpoint meeting to review early signals from remediation actions.
- Timeline Recap
- Produce a prioritized list of concrete improvements to prevent repeat issues and increase operational maturity.
- Assign owners and timelines for each improvement with measurable acceptance criteria.
- Capture institutional knowledge to update runbooks, onboarding, and integration guides.
- Create and circulate a Retrospective Report with prioritized improvements, owners, timelines, and acceptance criteria within 3 business days.
- Update deployment runbooks and onboarding checklists to reflect agreed process changes.
- Assign a PM to track improvement completion and report status at the next success checkpoint.
- Opening & Objectives
- Ensure the merchant validates reported business outcomes and is satisfied with early results.
- Business Impact Summary
- Monitoring & Alerting Review
- KPI Dashboard Walkthrough
- Impact x Effort Scoring
- What Went Well
- Runbooks, Rollback & Contingency Plans
- Gap Analysis & Root Causes
- Merchant Feedback & Prioritized Pain Points
- What Didn't Go Well / Incidents
- Roadmap Fit & Release Windows
- Decisions & Experiment Definitions
- Root Cause Themes & Improvement Opportunities
- Wins, Anomalies, and Risk Signals
- Shared Channel & Escalation Paths
- Escalation Paths & SLA Commitments
- Prioritize & Assign Improvements
- Agree Follow-ups & Cadence
- Decision & Next Steps
- Training & Handover Actions