Workers Compensation Claims
Complex multi-party engagements where risk, regulation, and claim resolution require coordinated action.
Inside this journey
-
Pre-Discovery
Align the room on outcomes, decision process, and constraints before deeper discovery.
-
Stakeholder Alignment
Confirm decision roles, timeline, procurement constraints, and what ‘good’ looks like for each stakeholder.
Alignment Questions
Quick Check‑In: Who's in Your Corner?
- Who will be attending or directly involved in decisions about workers' comp claims strategy for this initiative?
- Which single stakeholder holds primary sign‑off authority for vendor selection or operational changes?
- How would you summarize what 'good' looks like to your executive sponsor in one sentence?
- Are there others whose buy‑in we should secure early to avoid later rework?
- Have there been recent reorganizations, audits, or personnel changes that affect decision timelines or risk tolerance?
If Nothing Changes, What Keeps You Awake?
- What would be the real cost—financial, operational, or reputational—if your current claims path stayed the same for the next 12–18 months?
- Which outcome areas concern you most when you picture 'business as usual' continuing?
- Who in your organization feels the impact of those outcomes most acutely, and how do they usually show their concern?
- Tell us about a recent claim or trend that best captures the problem you’re most worried about—what happened and why did it matter?
- When a claim spirals, what internal workflow or escalation typically breaks down first?
Who Really Holds the Power (Even When They Don't Show It)?
- Which informal influencers—opinion leaders, adjuster champions, outside advisors—can quietly make or break adoption of a new claims model?
- Which of those influencers have historically resisted vendor recommendations, and what were their reasons?
- Who would be responsible for day‑to‑day governance of a pilot or rollout, and where would that role sit in your org?
- What engagement approach typically converts skeptics here—hard data, a short pilot, executive sponsorship, or hands‑on training?
- What evidence or experience would make those informal influencers publicly champion a change?
When 'Good' Differs by Title — Tell Us What Each Stakeholder Needs
- If the Risk Manager wrote a one‑line definition of success for this program, what would it say?
- For the VP of Claims / TPA leader, which measurable targets define success?
- What financial metric and timeline would the CFO need to see to approve investment?
- What legal or compliance conditions must be satisfied before Legal will approve execution (e.g., data controls, indemnity language, MSAs)?
- From the employee or union perspective, what outcomes or service standards must we meet to avoid pushback?
Procurement Speed Bump: What's Really Slowing You Down?
- What's the single procurement or contracting barrier that has torpedoed similar projects before?
- How long do procurement and contracting cycles typically take here for services like ours?
- Which teams must sign off on contracts and which clauses create the most negotiation (select all that apply)?
- Do you have pre‑existing vendor agreements, master service agreements, or procurement frameworks that could accelerate onboarding?
- Which compliance or certification documents do we need to provide up front (e.g., SOC2, HIPAA, state licensure)?
Small Pilots, Big Proof: How Would You Test It?
- If you had to design a pilot your toughest skeptic couldn't ignore, what would be the one metric it must move?
- What pilot duration and scale would feel persuasive for meaningful decision‑making?
- Which KPI set would you prioritize to convince Finance, Claims, and Clinical leaders (choose up to three)?
- What claim types, severities, or jurisdictions should we include to make the pilot representative and defensible?
- What operational constraints must a pilot respect (adjuster caseload, system integration windows, union rules, etc.)?
- Who would be the internal 'pilot owner' with authority to act on results and remove blockers?
The Unsaid Commitments: Timeline, Resources, and Signals to Proceed
- What would you need to see, hear, or receive to feel comfortable saying 'let's start' in the next quarter?
- What budget authority or funding cadence is available today for a pilot or initial engagement?
- Which of these data sources are you willing and able to share for pilot setup?
- What privacy, security, or governance approvals will be required before data transfer, and how long do they typically take?
- What internal governance cadence will you commit to during pilot (so decisions aren’t delayed)?
- Are there any blackout periods, fiscal deadlines, or other calendar constraints that would prevent a near‑term start?
-
Current State Mapping
Document current claims workflows, failure modes, and key drivers (medical escalation, opioids, indemnity duration, attorney involvement, regulatory constraints).
Current State
Paint Your Current Claim Landscape
- How are new workplace injury reports most commonly submitted today?
- Walk me through, step‑by‑step, what happens from the initial report to the first clinical outreach—who does what and in what timeframe?
- What is your average new claim volume per week and how predictable is that volume?
- Which claim types make up the majority of your caseload?
- Describe your adjuster structure and jurisdictional coverage—how many adjusters per claims, and who has specialized state expertise?
- Which systems capture your claim and medical data today?
Are We Letting Small Problems Become Big Ones?
- Which routine early decisions in your current workflow most often precede a claim escalating into costly care or litigation?
- How quickly do you typically make clinical contact (nurse/physician) after a new report?
- What typically triggers nurse case management or utilization review today?
- How do you detect and act on early opioid use or potentially inappropriate prescribing?
- Tell us about a recent claim that escalated quickly—what early signals were missed and how did that make the team feel?
Where the Dollars Leak — and Why It Hurts
- How many claims would you describe as ‘inefficient but tolerable’—the ones you don’t fix because fixing them feels harder than writing the check?
- What are your current average KPIs: medical spend per claim, indemnity days lost, and litigation rate (or best estimates)?
- Which of these cost drivers have the biggest negative impact on your loss ratio right now?
- Which worker cohorts or claim causes disproportionately drive your catastrophic or long‑tail spend?
- How does this financial pressure show up in your internal conversations—what keeps leaders awake about claims spend?
Who’s Pulling the Strings (and Who’s Missing From the Table)
- Who ultimately owns decisions that materially change claim outcomes—clinical protocols, pharmacy rules, RTW policies—and are they represented in procurement conversations?
- Which internal stakeholders most often resist changes to clinical or pharmacy practices, and why?
- How do you currently document and communicate jurisdictional responsibilities (state rules, payer obligations, MSA thresholds) between teams?
- Who would need to sign off for us to implement clinical pathways, pharmacy prior‑auth rules, or a RTW pilot?
- Tell us about a time a stakeholder handoff failed—what happened and what would you have wanted done differently?
Regulatory Minefields and Local Rules
- Which state rule, reporting quirk, or regulatory practice has cost you time or money recently—what did it reveal about your readiness?
- Which jurisdictions drive the most complexity for you today?
- How integrated are your processes with Medicare conditional payment handling and MSA preparation?
- Have recent regulatory changes required you to change clinical or reimbursement practices? Give an example.
- What compliance checks or approvals typically delay clinical interventions or RTW placements?
Signals That Tell Us a Claim Will Go Bad (sooner than you think)
- Looking back at claims that ended up litigated or chronic, what single early signal would you have wanted flagged sooner?
- Which of these early signals do you currently track or alert on?
- How often do you use predictive analytics to prioritize claims for clinical outreach?
- Give a concrete example of a claim that our early‑warning rules should have caught—what data would have changed the outcome?
- Which signals, if acted on within the first 7–14 days, do you believe would most reduce long‑term spend?
What Would Meaningful Early Change Actually Look Like?
- If early intervention reduced average indemnity days by 20% and medical spend per claim by 15%, what would that mean for your team and budget?
- Which KPI shifts would convince leadership to scale a pilot into a program?
- What minimum ROI or payback period would you require to commit to a statewide or multi‑jurisdiction rollout?
- How would you prefer success be demonstrated—quantitative savings, improved worker outcomes, regulatory risk reduction, or a combination?
- What cultural or operational barriers would we need to address to make early changes stick?
Immediate First Steps We’d Take Together
- If we agreed to a 90‑day proof of concept, what data and operational access could you realistically provide?
- Which data elements are readily available to share: initial visit notes, prescription history, RTW status, adjuster notes, or billing detail?
- Who on your team would be the day‑to‑day contact for a pilot, and who needs to be kept informed?
- What timeline and decision gates do you have for piloting new clinical or pharmacy controls?
- What would make you say ‘yes’ this quarter to a focused pilot—we’ll be candid about what we need and what you’ll need to see.
-
-
Outcome Discovery
Define target outcomes, measurable success signals (cost per claim, days lost, litigation rate), and the conditions required to achieve them.
Discovery Questions
Quick Wins: Where Do We Start?
- What one outcome would feel like an early win for your team in the first 90 days?
- Tell us about a recent claim or situation that, if handled differently, would have made that 90‑day win possible—what happened?
- Which of these short-term levers do you have the appetite to deploy quickly?
- Who on your side would champion a 90‑day pilot and be accountable for quick decisions?
- How will you want early progress communicated (format and cadence)?
If We Keep Doing What We're Doing…
- What’s the single biggest cost or outcome that keeps you up at night about your current claims performance?
- How have those metrics trended over the last 12–24 months (improving, flat, worsening)?
- If those trends continue for another year, what operational or financial consequences do you expect?
- Which silent costs matter most but rarely make it into monthly reports (e.g., employer morale, lost productivity, recruitment challenges)?
- How long have you been tolerating the current state before deciding a change is necessary?
What 'Good' Actually Looks Like for Your Team
- If you could reframe success beyond dollars—what three outcomes would make you say this program was transformational?
- For each stakeholder below, what does 'good' look like for them? (Risk manager, VP of claims, CFO, Legal, HR)
- Which of those stakeholder outcomes are currently aligned—and where are the biggest gaps?
- Which stakeholder outcome is non-negotiable for you to move forward (pick one)?
- How would achieving these outcomes change your internal narrative about workers’ comp (e.g., from cost center to predictable program)?
The Numbers That Prove It
- Which measurable signals are you most likely to judge as proof of success?
- What are your current baseline values for the top three signals you selected? Please list metric → baseline (e.g., Cost per claim = $X)
- What realistic improvement targets do you expect at 6, 12, and 24 months for each selected metric?
- What minimum improvement would make the program worth the investment (i.e., your go/no-go threshold)?
- Do you have preferred ROI or payback-period rules we should design to—such as % reduction in severity or months to break-even?
What Has To Change — and What Can't
- If we asked you to make one operational change to get the outcomes you just described, what would you be willing to change immediately—and what is absolutely off the table?
- Which of these constraints apply to your program right now?
- How flexible is your claims decisioning for early interventions (e.g., single-adjuster authority, nurse-led decisions, centralized approvals)?
- What legal or regulatory guardrails must our interventions respect in your jurisdictions?
- What would a failed change look like to you—what are the harms or risks we must avoid?
Who's Holding the Keys?
- Who are the decision-makers and approvers for outcome commitments, budgets, and pilot scope on your side?
- Which roles will need to be involved in day‑to‑day pilot governance (claims lead, clinical lead, legal, finance, HR)?
- Who controls the data feeds and how quickly can you share anonymized claims for baseline analysis?
- What decision criteria will the CFO or actuarial team use to sign off on scaling beyond a pilot?
- Are there internal champions who will actively promote change—and who might quietly resist? Please name roles, not individuals.
How We'll Know When to Scale or Stop
- What concrete go/no‑go criteria would you set for a pilot (include metric thresholds, minimum sample size, and timeline)?
- Which pilot duration feels acceptable to you to demonstrate statistical and operational confidence?
- What sample size or claim types should be prioritized in the pilot to give you confidence (e.g., high-severity, soft-tissue, opioid-exposed)?
- What reporting cadence and level of detail will help you decide to scale (raw claims, cohort analytics, executive summary)?
- If early signals are mixed, what escalation path should we follow to refine approach before deciding?
Unspoken Barriers: Emotions, Politics, and Culture
- What worries do you hear from colleagues when you mention changing claims approach—fear of losing control, liability concerns, or something else?
- How do front-line adjusters and nurse case managers feel about more clinical or pharmacy-led interventions—curious, skeptical, or actively resistant?
- What internal communications or change supports would make your teams more comfortable (training, shadowing, joint case reviews)?
- If we succeed, what cultural change do you hope to see in how claims are managed a year from now?
- Is there anything else—an anecdote, a fear, or an aspiration—we should know that won't fit neatly into metrics but matters to whether this succeeds?
-
Solution Experience
Apply our clinical, pharmacy, and RTW interventions to the customer’s real claim scenarios to validate expected outcomes and ROI.
Experience Meetings
- Pre‑Experience Alignment
- Data & Claim Selection Workshop
- Intervention Simulation Session (Claim-Level Diagnosis & Proof)
- Results Review & ROI Validation
- Recommendation & Pilot Decision
- Customer to review ROI workbook, confirm or correct input assumptions, and sign off on pilot acceptance criteria.
- If necessary, customer to run de‑identification and certify compliance before transfer.
- Methodology & Assumptions Review
- Produce per-claim documented interventions and projected KPI changes (cost, days, litigation risk).
- Demonstrate direct causal links between interventions and the defined future state.
- Identify any practical obstacles to executing interventions at scale (data, provider access, employment restrictions).
- Host to produce an interventions workbook with line-item projected savings and timeline changes per claim.
- Customer to validate clinical assumptions for each claim and flag any factual corrections.
- Clinical/pharmacy teams to note any provider or formulary constraints that may change projected outcomes.
- Consolidated Outcome Summary
- Deliver a validated ROI workbook the customer accepts as the basis for decision-making.
- Agree on realistic ranges for expected outcomes and the variables that most influence results.
- Set clear, measurable acceptance criteria for the pilot phase.
- Host to deliver the final ROI workbook and assumptions document within 48 hours.
- Introductions & Objectives
- Together, produce a risk mitigation plan for the top 3 sensitivity drivers.
- Recap of Experience & Validated Outcomes
- Obtain mutual agreement to proceed to a defined pilot with documented scope, KPIs, and timeline.
- Assign owners for pilot execution, data delivery, and governance meetings.
- Identify outstanding commercial/legal items and commit to dates for resolution.
- Draft and circulate a pilot SOW and project plan capturing scope, metrics, timeline, and owners.
- Legal and procurement to produce draft data‑sharing agreement and signoff checklist.
- Schedule pilot kickoff (date and invite) and initial governance cadence (weekly/monthly) with named owners.
- Customer to confirm budget/PO or commercial signoff needed to begin pilot.
- Produce and document a crystal-clear one-sentence current state.
- Surface and quantify the concrete consequences (cost/days/litigation) of the current state.
- Agree a one-sentence future state tied to measurable KPIs.
- Finalize claim selection criteria, data access needs, and prework owners/timelines.
- Owner to record and circulate the agreed one-sentence current state and future state.
- Customer to provide top-line consequence metrics (average cost per claim, avg days lost, litigation rate) by agreed date.
- Define and share claim selection criteria and sample size (e.g., 8–12 representative claims) and designate data owners.
- Legal/Privacy to confirm any de‑identification or access controls required before claim data exchange.
- Data Inventory & Schema Review
- Confirm data completeness and identify any gaps blocking the experience.
- Agree on the final set of representative claims to be used for intervention application.
- Establish a remediation timeline and owners for any data issues.
- Customer to deliver secured claim packets for the agreed list by the confirmed date.
- Host (clinical/pharmacy) to provide a data checklist and confirm any additional fields needed.
- IT/security to validate transfer mechanism and grant access to named reviewers.
- Claim Round 1 – Clinical Intervention
- ROI Model Walkthrough
- Current State (one-sentence)
- Recommended Pilot Scope & Objectives
- Claim Packet Spot‑check
- Operational Requirements & Responsibilities
- Consequence Quantification
- Sensitivity & Risk Scenarios
- Claim Round 2 – Pharmacy Intervention
- Representative Claim Selection
- Claim Round 3 – RTW Intervention
- Validation Q&A (Force Agreement)
- Future State (one-sentence) & Success Metrics
- Data Quality Remediation Plan
- Success Criteria, KPIs & Governance Cadence
- Claim Selection Criteria & Logistics
- Commercial & Legal Next Steps
- Confirm Delivery & Access
- Define Acceptance Criteria for Pilot
- Cross‑Claim Summary & Tie‑back
- Risks & Constraints
-
Solution Scope
Define included services, jurisdictional responsibilities, integration points, KPIs, and acceptance criteria for the proposed model.
Scope Configuration
- 24/7 Injury Reporting and Nurse-Led Clinical Triage
- Dedicated Jurisdictional Claims Administration
- Nurse Case Management for Complex Injuries
- Utilization Review and Prior Authorization Management
- Pharmacy Benefit Management with Opioid Controls
- Medical Bill Review and Provider Negotiation
- Access to Preferred Provider Network and Direct Billing
- Return-to-Work Coordination and Modified Duty Placement
- Medicare Set-Aside Preparation and Administration
- Subrogation Identification and Recovery Services
- Claim-Level Predictive Modeling and Risk Flagging
- Loss Trending and Frequency/Severity Benchmark Reporting
Scope Questions
24/7 Injury Reporting and Nurse-Led Clinical Triage
- Should 24/7 reporting and nurse triage be included in scope for this account?
- Which reporting channels should be supported (select all that apply)?
- Expected average volume of injury reports per month?
- What languages should triage support?
- Required maximum response time SLA for initial triage contact?
- Are there specific escalation rules or clinical pathways to apply during triage (e.g., immediate ER referral, onsite first aid)?
- Provide any special considerations for workplace / industry risk factors or seasonal surges (open text).
Dedicated Jurisdictional Claims Administration
- Do you require dedicated adjusters with jurisdiction-specific licensing and expertise?
- Which jurisdictions/states will be in scope? (select all that apply or choose 'Multiple - list')
- Estimated number of open workers' comp claims by jurisdiction at go-live?
- Are there state-specific reporting or regulatory templates we must adopt?
- Do you require state-specific indemnity calculation support (e.g., wage formulas, comp rate overrides)?
- Should jurisdictional claims be grouped by industry or account site for assignment?
- Are there preferred local offices, TPAs, or vendors you want us to coordinate with? (list)
Nurse Case Management for Complex Injuries
- Should nurse case management be deployed for complex claims?
- How do you define 'complex' for case management eligibility?
- Estimated number of complex claims per month to enroll in case management?
- Preferred model of case management?
- Primary objectives for nurse case management (select up to 3)?
- Any required KPIs or targets for case management (e.g., average days to RTW, reduction in LOS)? Provide values if known.
- Are there union, employer, or provider relationships that impact field visits or nurse access (specify)?
Utilization Review and Prior Authorization Management
- Do you want utilization review (UR) and prior authorization included?
- Which service categories should trigger UR/prior authorization (select all that apply)?
- Desired UR turnaround SLA for standard requests?
- Who will be primary contact for appeals and peer-to-peer discussions?
- Do you require tracking of prior auth denials and downstream clinical outcomes?
- Is integration with provider EMR or referral platforms required for UR workflows?
- Provide any special criteria or protocols to apply for high-cost procedures (open text).
Pharmacy Benefit Management with Opioid Controls
- Should PBM services with opioid controls be included?
- Current average monthly pharmacy spend and percent opioid-related (if known)?
- Which opioid-control strategies are required (select all that apply)?
- Do you require integration with pharmacy claims feeds or e-prescribing systems?
- Preferred dispensing model?
- Are there state-specific controlled substance rules we must enforce (list states)?
- Target metrics for PBM (e.g., opioid scripts reduction %, pharmacy spend reduction %) — please specify.
Medical Bill Review and Provider Negotiation
- Do you want medical bill review and active provider negotiation included?
- Average number of medical bills per month and typical billed amount ranges?
- Do you have existing repricing or fee schedule agreements we must honor?
- Should vendor negotiation include ER/ambulance and out-of-network claims?
- Are Medicare compliance (billing, MSA offsets) and anti-kickback considerations required in review?
- What savings targets or benchmarks would indicate acceptable performance for bill review (open text)?
- Any provider groups or facilities excluded from negotiation (list)?
Access to Preferred Provider Network and Direct Billing
- Do you require access to a preferred provider network and direct billing arrangements?
- Is network coverage required across all states in scope or specific regions?
- Do you have an existing network we must integrate with or replace?
- Should direct billing be to employer, carrier, or third-party payer?
- Are telehealth/virtual provider options required within the network?
- Any credentialing or provider contracting constraints we should be aware of?
- Target metrics for network utilization and direct-billing adoption (open text).
Return-to-Work Coordination and Modified Duty Placement
- Should RTW coordination and modified duty placement be included?
- Do you have existing employer-partner sites willing to accept modified duty?
- Desired maximum duration for transitional/modified duty assignments?
- Who will own job analysis and accommodation decisions (select one)?
- Required RTW KPIs (select up to 3)?
- Are there collective bargaining or legal restrictions on modified duty in your workforce?
- Any examples of ideal modified duty roles or job descriptions to reference (open text)?
Medicare Set-Aside Preparation and Administration
- Will any claimants be Medicare-eligible now or anticipated to be in the future?
- Do you require CMS submission and approval services for MSAs?
- Who should administer MSA funds (select one)?
- Estimated number of claims annually requiring MSA services?
-
Mutual Commit
Agree commercial terms, SLAs, data-sharing, governance cadence, and legal modules required to start the engagement.
Agreement Modules
- Master Services Agreement (MSA)
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Commercial Terms & Pricing Schedule
- Service Level Agreement (SLA)
- Data Sharing & Interface Agreement
- Data Processing Agreement / HIPAA Business Associate Addendum (BAA)
- Security & Compliance Addendum
- Governance & Reporting Cadence
- Implementation & Acceptance Plan (Pilot Criteria)
- Provider Network & PBM Access Agreement
- Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) & Medicare Compliance Addendum
- Subrogation & Recovery Terms
- Change Order & Scope Amendment
- Termination, Offboarding & Data Return Plan
- Insurance, Indemnity & Liability Schedule
- Billing Authorization & Payment Setup
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Confirm data feeds, system access, provider network connections, MSA/Medicare processes, and compliance requirements are in place.
Readiness Questions
Getting Started: Tell Us About Your Claims World
- Briefly describe your organization and the population you manage for workers' compensation (size, industries, locations).
- Which best describes your organization?
- What was your total workers' comp claim volume (closed claims) in the last 12 months?
- What is your current average total paid medical cost per indemnity claim (most recent 12 months)?
- Who owns the KPIs tied to claims performance inside your organization? (Select all that apply.)
- Tell us about a recent claim that best represents the problem you want solved—what happened and why did it matter?
Are You Comfortable With the Costs You See?
- Which costs are you silently tolerating because they feel inevitable—and what would it mean to be able to challenge them?
- Which of these are the primary drivers of cost inflation in your book of business? (Select up to 4.)
- How does your current litigation/attorney involvement rate compare to your internal target or industry benchmark?
- Which cost element feels most unpredictable month to month?
- When cost spikes happen, who in your organization feels the impact most viscerally (emotionally and operationally)?
What Keeps You Up at Night About Outcomes?
- When you picture a worst-case claim outcome, what is the single image or consequence that makes you most anxious?
- How do injured worker outcomes factor into your decision-making compared with pure dollar metrics?
- Which three outcome metrics would you insist improve for a program to be considered successful?
- How important is improving time-to-first-contact (triage) in your view of improving outcomes?
- Describe the emotional or reputational consequences inside your organization when a claim goes sideways (e.g., executive reaction, client complaints, union issues).
Where Are the Bottlenecks Hiding?
- Which single process failure—if fixed tomorrow—would shorten claim duration the most?
- How quickly are new claims triaged today?
- Where do handoffs most commonly break down? (Select all that apply.)
- How prevalent are delays due to missing or late clinical documentation (notes, IME, diagnostic reports)?
- Give an example of a recent handoff that failed and the downstream impact it created (timing, cost, outcomes).
If You Could Rewire a Claim From Day One
- Imagine a claim handled perfectly from day one—what would you see differently in the first 30, 90, and 365 days?
- Which of these improvements would signal success early in a pilot? (Select up to 4.)
- What level of percent improvement in key KPIs within 12 months would you consider a clear win?
- Which clinical, pharmacy, or RTW interventions have you tried already, and what stopped them from getting traction?
- If we could guarantee one operational change during the pilot (e.g., 24-hour triage, dedicated nurse case manager, pharmacy lock-in), which would you pick and why?
What Would It Take to Trust a New Partner?
- What vendor behavior during onboarding makes you lose trust faster than anything else?
- Which proof points would most accelerate your trust? (Select all that apply.)
- Which legal, compliance, or procurement items are non-negotiable before you’ll start data exchange or a pilot? (Select all that apply.)
- Who on your side must sign off for a new claims partner to start a pilot, and what will each person's top concern likely be?
- How important are financial risk-sharing models (shared savings, fee-for-service reductions) to your decision to move forward?
The Data and Systems Reality Check — Are We Ready?
- If your data could answer one question about your claims right now, what would you want it to reveal?
- Which of these data feeds can you provide today? (Select all that apply.)
- How would you rate the quality and completeness of the claims data we’d receive?
- Which technical exchange methods are acceptable to your IT/legal teams? (Select all that apply.)
- Are there contractual, legal, or platform blockers (e.g., union rules, vendor exclusivity, legacy contracts) that typically delay data sharing? Please describe.
Pilot to Full Rollout: What Would Make You Say Yes?
- What single pilot failure would cause you to cancel the program outright?
- What pilot structure would you prefer to validate value? (Select one.)
- Which go/no-go criteria should be included in the pilot agreement? (Select up to 4.)
- How frequently would you expect governance and performance reviews during a 90-day pilot?
- What internal resources (roles and approximate FTE/time allocation) can you commit to a 90-day pilot?
Stakeholder Map — Who Holds the Real Levers?
- Who in your organization can stop this project with a single negative decision, and why would they say no?
- For each of these roles, tell us their primary success criteria for a claims program. (Select all relevant roles.)
- What procurement or budget timeline constraints should we plan around (e.g., fiscal year, board reviews, renewal windows)?
- Have you run an RFP or formal procurement for these services in the last 24 months? If yes, what was the outcome and main learning?
- What previous vendor experiences or pilot results should we be aware of so we don't repeat past mistakes?
-
Deployment Enablement
Schedule tasks, assign owners, train adjusters and clinical teams, and execute pilot claims with monitoring.
-
Validation Checklist
Verify pilot KPIs, data integrity, workflow handoffs, and go/no-go criteria for full-scale rollout.
Validation Questions
Quick Warm-Up — Tell Us About Today
- What is your role and primary responsibility for workers' compensation?
- Which organization type best describes you?
- Roughly how many new indemnity claims do you handle per year?
- How are claims currently administered at your organization?
- What one success metric matters most to your leadership today?
Are We Quietly Accepting Broken Claims?
- Do you ever find yourself tolerating claims that keep getting more expensive without a clear plan to change that trajectory?
- Which recurring claim problems frustrate you most right now? Select all that apply.
- Tell us about the most recent claim that felt like it slipped away from you — what happened and why did it stick in your memory?
- How often do early-stage claims (first 30 days) show signs that they will become high-cost or litigated?
- When a claim begins to escalate, what is the emotional impact on your team and stakeholders?
What’s Hiding in the Bottom Line?
- Which hidden or indirect costs worry you most (beyond headline medical spend)?
- Can you quantify average medical spend and indemnity per closed claim over the last 12 months? If not exact, please estimate.
- Which claim types or injury categories disproportionately drive your severity?
- How do you currently measure litigation propensity or the likelihood a claim will involve an attorney?
- Share a recent example where a 'small' claim turned expensive — what early signals were missed, and how would you have wanted it handled differently?
Where Early Intervention Actually Breaks Down
- Why do so many organizations think they’re intervening early when, in reality, the intervention comes too late?
- How fast does a new claim typically get a clinical touch (phone triage, nurse outreach, or similar)?
- Describe how first notice of injury flows today — who gets notified, what systems are used, and where handoffs commonly fail.
- Do you have standardized protocols (scripts, escalation thresholds) for adjusters and nurse case managers to follow in the first 7–14 days?
- When early clinical intervention happens, what barriers most often limit its impact?
What Would True Success Feel Like?
- If you could wave a wand, what three measurable results would convince your CEO that the claims program is working?
- Which of these KPIs would you prioritize for a pilot that proves value?
- What minimum percentage improvement on your top KPI would you consider a successful pilot?
- How would improved claim outcomes change decisions outside of claims (e.g., pricing, reserve strategy, safety programs)?
- Which stakeholder beyond claims must see the metrics to sign off on a full rollout?
Who Holds the Keys — Internal Politics and Decision Triggers
- Who are the required approvers for a new claims model and what does each one need to be convinced?
- What procurement, contracting, or budgeting constraints typically slow you down?
- What non-financial concerns (reputation, employee relations, regulatory scrutiny) carry the most weight in approvals?
- What internal stories or past vendor experiences would we need to address up front to build trust?
- What is your target timeline for making a decision about piloting a new model?
Designing a Pilot You Can't Say No To
- What would make a pilot effectively impossible to refuse internally?
- What pilot size and scope feels credible to you (claims count, jurisdictions, lines of business)?
- Which go/no‑go criteria should govern scaling from pilot to full deployment?
- What specific data access or sample claims would we need to run a meaningful pilot for your program?
- Who on your team would be the day-to-day owner of the pilot and who are the executive sponsors?
Can Our Tech and Data Actually Play Nicely Together?
- Where do your biggest integration pain points live — claims platform, billing data, Rx feeds, or reporting?
- Which claims systems and major vendor platforms will we need to connect to for a pilot?
- How timely and complete are your data feeds today (e.g., FROI/SROI, bills, Rx) — and where do gaps appear?
- What level of data validation or reconciliation would be required before you consider the pilot results reliable?
- What cadence and format of reporting will your stakeholders expect during a pilot?
Risk, Compliance, and the Fine Print
- What regulatory or compliance requirements are non-negotiable for any vendor engagement in your jurisdictions?
- Do you have a Medicare-eligible population that requires MSA planning or centralized MSA administration?
- How have past audits or regulatory reviews influenced the controls you require from vendors?
- What legal or indemnity terms do you insist on before a pilot can start (e.g., limits, indemnities, data usage)?
- Are there any state-specific issues (fee schedules, utilization rules, claimant protections) we should know before designing the solution?
Next Moves — Small Wins That Build Confidence
- If you had to pick one immediate action that would reduce friction and accelerate a pilot, what would it be?
- Who on your side can commit the time this quarter to support discovery, data preparation, and pilot launch?
- What are the top three blockers we must remove to get to an agreed statement of work?
- How soon could you provide a sample dataset (de‑identified) or claims extract for a pilot feasibility review?
- On a scale from 1–10, how ready is your organization to pilot a new claims model within the next 90 days? Explain your score.
-
-
Success
Review performance against agreed KPIs, capture lessons, and maintain a shared channel for issues and continuous improvement.
Success Reviews
- KPI Performance Review (Quarterly)
- Operational Pulse — Monthly Triage
- Lessons Learned & Process Improvement Workshop
- Governance & Continuous Improvement Cadence
- Data Integrity & KPI Validation Audit
Issues & Enhancements
- Secure approvals for prioritized backlog items that require executive sign-off.
- Schedule targeted micro-training sessions for adjusters or nurses where gaps are identified.
- Pre-work Recap & Objectives
- Surface and document concrete lessons from recent cohorts and cases.
- Agree on 2–4 prioritized pilot experiments with clear success metrics and owners.
- Establish timelines and reporting expectations for pilots and rollouts.
- Update playbooks or SOPs with any immediately actionable process changes.
- Publish a lessons-learned dossier with anonymized claim examples and recommended changes.
- Create pilot charters for each agreed experiment including metrics and data needs.
- Assign sponsors and schedule pilot kickoff meetings and weekly check-ins.
- Update training materials and SOPs for any low-effort, high-impact fixes.
- Review Open Action Tracker
- Ensure ongoing alignment and accountability for KPI achievement and improvements.
- Keep the continuous improvement backlog prioritized and resourced appropriately.
- Maintain a clear, governed shared channel with SLAs and escalation rules.
- Capture and approve any governance-level decisions or budget reallocations.
- Update the shared CustomerNode channel with current action statuses and owners.
- Welcome & Objectives
- Schedule the next governance meeting and circulate required pre-read materials.
- Escalate any unresolved compliance or contract risks to legal and sponsor leads.
- Scope & Pre-work Review
- Confirm data pipeline integrity for KPI reporting and identify any systemic gaps.
- Agree on unambiguous KPI definitions and reconcile calculation differences.
- Create an actionable remediation plan for any data or calculation discrepancies.
- Obtain formal sign-off on validated KPIs or a clear timeline for re-validation.
- Log data correction tickets with technical owners and target remediation dates.
- Update and publish a KPI definition and calculation playbook for all stakeholders.
- Implement automated monitoring alerts for feed failures or anomalous KPI shifts.
- Schedule a follow-up validation to confirm remediation results and obtain final sign-off.
- Validate quarter-to-date performance against contractual KPI targets and benchmarks.
- Identify and agree on the top 3 root causes driving KPI variance.
- Approve a timebound action plan with named owners and success criteria.
- Confirm any changes required to KPI definitions, dashboard calculations, or reporting cadence.
- Produce a prioritized remediation plan with owners, milestones, and measurable outcomes.
- Update KPI dashboard definitions and publish a reconciliation note for stakeholders.
- Schedule follow-up deep-dive meetings for any unresolved high-impact claims or cohorts.
- Distribute meeting minutes and the action tracker to governance participants within 48 hours.
- Opening & Status Round
- Close or progress high-priority operational issues within agreed SLAs.
- Ensure owners and timelines are assigned for each open item.
- Prevent repeat incidents by identifying short-term process or training fixes.
- Create/assign escalation tickets with SLA targets for unresolved items.
- Publish a one-page operational bulletin for affected teams outlining immediate fixes.
- KPI Snapshot
- KPI Trend Brief
- Success Cases & Failure Cases Presentation
- Open Escalations Review
- Data Feed & ETL Status
- Improvement Backlog Prioritization
- Deep Dive — Medical Cost per Claim
- Data & Workflow Exceptions
- Root Cause Mapping (Breakouts)
- KPI Definition Reconciliation
- Risk, Compliance & Contract Items
- Prioritize Improvement Opportunities
- Deep Dive — Indemnity Duration & Days Lost
- Sample Reconciliation
- Provider & Network Issues
- Design Pilot Experiments
- Remediation Plan & Monitoring