New Product Introduction
Complex technical sales and manufacturing engagements across the global electronics supply chain.
Inside this journey
-
Pre-Discovery
Align decision makers, timelines, and risk tolerance before technical work.
-
Stakeholder Alignment
Confirm decision roles, locked launch date, risk tolerance, and escalation paths before technical work begins.
Alignment Questions
Quick Context — Your Launch in One Line
- In one sentence, describe the product you want manufactured, where it sits in development (prototype / beta / validated), and the committed launch date.
- Which best describes your current product type and complexity?
- Who on your team will be our primary day-to-day contact for technical decisions during NPI?
- How visible is this program inside your company—what level of leadership is tracking the launch?
- What three outcomes would make this NPI engagement feel like a clear success for your leadership?
Is Your Launch a Ticking Clock or a Comfortable Cushion?
- If your committed launch date slipped by one month, how close would that come to creating serious executive or customer consequences?
- Is the launch date formally locked (contractual or customer pledge), or is it internal/aspirational?
- If a schedule risk emerged, who has authority to approve a date change and what’s the escalation path?
- What are the downstream consequences (sales, regulatory, integration partners) if we miss that date?
- How tolerant is your executive team of scrap, rework, or a phased ramp to protect the date?
Where the Hidden Breaks Live
- What’s the one part of your design you’d be most surprised to see fail at scale?
- Describe your current validation status—which tests have been done on prototypes and which haven’t?
- Which failure modes have you already observed in lab or field prototypes? Please give examples and frequency.
- Where do you suspect your design was optimized for lab-proof rather than production repeatability?
- How would you rank the likelihood of late-discovered failure modes delaying ramp (1 = extremely unlikely, 5 = almost certain)?
Supply Chain Squeeze — How Fragile Is Your BOM?
- If a single component in your BOM became unavailable, how easily could you qualify an alternate supplier or part?
- Do you have parts that are single-source, long-lead, or custom that are critical to launch? Please list the top 3 and the current lead times.
- How complete is your BOM and ECO history (mechanical drawings, part attributes, approved alternates)?
- What is your tolerance for approved part substitutions during NPI? (e.g., acceptable with testing, require full sign-off, or not allowed)
- Who owns sourcing/alternates on your side and how quickly can they support qualification of new suppliers?
Who Really Decides When To Say ‘Go’?
- When push comes to shove, who signs off that a pilot is acceptable to proceed to full rate—engineering, quality, operations, or commercial?
- Describe your preferred change-control and ECO governance—fast, centralized, consensus or staged approvals?
- What acceptance criteria (tests, yields, FAI results, supplier qualifications) would you require before we move from pilot to ramp?
- If we propose a stop-build condition during pilot, what thresholds would you expect (e.g., yield < X, critical failure rate > Y)?
- Who are the escalation contacts for technical, commercial, and supply issues, and what is the expected response time from each?
What Would a Clean Handoff Actually Feel Like?
- Imagine opening the box on day one of volume—what must be true for you to call the ramp successful?
- Which pilot metrics would you track most closely to decide if the process is stable (select top 3)?
- What pilot quantity do you consider minimally meaningful to validate processes and supplier readiness?
- What documentation or deliverables must be locked at handoff (work instructions, test programs, FAI report, supplier qualifications)?
- How important is preserving traceability (lot, serial, ECO history) during pilot and ramp to your post-launch support?
If Things Go Sideways, How Do You Want Us to Respond?
- When production issues arise, do you want immediate stop-build, partial containment, or continued builds while we iterate fixes?
- How quickly do you expect initial root-cause analysis and a proposed mitigation after a critical pilot failure?
- What commercial remedies or flex (expedited parts, price protection, warranty posture) would make you more comfortable accepting risk during ramp?
- Have you experienced a previous ramp failure or major ECO late in NPI? Tell us what happened and what you wish had been different.
- How would you like progress and risk to be reported (weekly dashboard, daily standup during pilot, exception reports only)?
Practical Evidence — Show Me the Docs
- Which of these assets do you already have ready to share? (select all that apply)
- If some assets aren’t available, which ones will take the longest to produce or extract?
- How do you prefer to grant technical access—shared drive, secure portal, or on-site review?
- Who on your team owns ECO history and change documentation and can walk us through prior design iterations?
- Are there IP, export, or data-security constraints we should know about before we request files?
-
Technical Package Readiness
Verify availability of design files, BOM, ECO history, test requirements, and target yields needed to scope NPI work.
Readiness Checklist
Start Line: Where Are We Starting From?
- What is the product name, SKU(s), and the committed launch date your executive team is expecting?
- Who is the single program owner we should coordinate with day-to-day (name, title, email)?
- How many product variants or SKUs are included in this program?
- How would you rate the program priority inside your company right now?
- Have you attempted a production ramp of this design elsewhere before? If yes, what happened?
What Will Blow Up If We Don’t Nail the BOM?
- If a single critical component shipment is late or obsolete, how badly could that derail your launch?
- How complete is the BOM you plan to hand over to us today?
- Which parts are sole-source, have long lead-times, or are single-fab custom items? (select all that apply)
- Do you maintain approved vendor lists (AVL) or supplier certificates for the BOM items you expect us to use?
- How often does your BOM change in the late stages (last 3 months)?
- If there are key shortage risks, which mitigation would you prefer us to pursue first?
Can the Files Actually Make a Product?
- How confident are you that the files in your repository are the exact set that produced a working prototype?
- Which design and manufacturing files can you provide immediately?
- Where are these files managed and how are revisions controlled?
- When was the last ECO applied to the design, and can you provide the ECO log or change list?
- Will you be providing golden/reference units, firmware images, or a functional acceptance unit for validation?
- Are there known mismatches between PCB fabrication drawings, assembly drawings, and the BOM that we should reconcile before quoting?
What in Your ECO History Keeps You Up at Night?
- Have late design changes (ECOs) ever forced rework, scrapped pilot builds, or missed customer dates for this product or similar ones?
- Roughly how many ECOs have been issued in the last six months for this program?
- What typically triggers an ECO at your company?
- Who signs off on ECOs and how quickly can approvals be obtained during an NPI sprint?
- Do you have a documented change-control process you want us to adopt, or should we propose one for alignment?
Could Your Test Plan Catch the Killers?
- If a failure mode exists that will reduce long-term yield by 30%, is that failure likely to be caught by your current test plan before pilot builds?
- Which test strategies and levels are included in your current plan? (select all that apply)
- Do you have existing test vectors, failure mode analyses (DFMEA), or known-defect lists we can review?
- What are the pass/fail criteria for the product at functional test and what margin do you expect?
- How do you triage test failures today and how quickly can design fixes be turned into ECOs and pushed to manufacturing?
- Are there specific test fixtures, probes, or software licenses we must procure or that you will supply?
Is Your Yield Goal Real or Aspirational?
- What target first-pass yield and final assembly yield numbers are you planning to achieve at pilot and at volume?
- Have you captured measured yields on prototypes or small builds? If so, under what test conditions and sample size?
- What defect rate or DPMO (defects per million opportunities) would be considered a launch failure?
- How much schedule or budget flexibility exists if we need additional ECO cycles to hit yield targets?
- What statistical confidence (sample size/CI) do you require before accepting pilot yields as representative?
Who's Got Skin in the Game When Things Go Sideways?
- When a production blocker appears, who has the authority at your company to make trade-offs between scope, timeline, and budget?
- Who will be our day-to-day technical contacts for design, test, and supply chain questions (name + role)?
- What escalation path and response SLAs do you expect for critical issues during NPI?
- How often should we provide status to your stakeholders (pilot data, ECOs, supply updates)?
- Are there specific stakeholders or external customers we must keep informed or who require approval before production release?
Sharing & Access: Are You Ready to Share the Goods?
- How comfortable is your team sharing IP, golden units, and firmware with a contract manufacturer under standard NDA protections?
- What legal or IP protections do you require for file transfers and physical samples?
- Will you provide firmware binaries, reference images, and secure keys for test, or do we need to validate without them?
- Are there export controls, ITAR, or data residency restrictions that will affect where or how the product can be manufactured?
- In what file formats do you prefer to transfer manufacturing data (select all that apply)?
-
-
Customer Discovery
Capture current validation status, known failure modes, supply constraints, and measurable success signals for the ramp.
Discovery Questions
Getting Comfortable — A Quick Snapshot
- Tell us the product name, a one-line description, and the primary market you’re targeting.
- Who is our day-to-day contact for technical decisions and who is the executive sponsor we should know about?
- What is your current target or committed launch date?
- How mission-critical is hitting that date to your business (reputation, revenue, customer commitments)?
- Briefly, what has your team already completed on validation and what still feels unfinished?
Where Things Tend to Break (Tell Us the Worst-Case You’re Preparing For)
- If this ramp failed, which single failure would you point to as the most likely root cause?
- Which failure modes have shown up in prototypes, lab tests, or pre-production builds?
- When those failure modes appeared, what was the typical impact on schedule, cost, or customer confidence?
- Who on your team currently owns root cause analysis and long-term corrective actions?
- Share one concrete example of a past root cause and the workaround you used — what worked and what didn’t?
The Supply Chain Tightrope (Where the Schedule Breaks First)
- If a single component became unavailable tomorrow, how fragile would your ability to meet the launch be?
- Which parts of your BOM are single-sourced or carry long lead times?
- Do you have qualified alternate parts or secondary suppliers for critical items?
- What past supplier issues (quality, capacity, lead time) have had the biggest schedule impact for you?
- From your perspective, which three supply risks should we prioritize together?
What Success on Ramp Actually Looks Like (Be Specific — No Vague KPIs)
- If this ramp is a success, name the three metrics your execs will celebrate and why.
- Which of these metrics are most critical to lock at pilot vs which are production-only?
- What are the minimum acceptable targets for those critical metrics?
- Who must formally accept pilot results and sign off on production release?
- Are there contractual milestones, penalties, or incentives tied to those metrics we should be aware of?
Hidden Validation & Test Gaps (The Things You Worry About in the Quiet Hours)
- What’s one failure mode you’re worried about but haven’t been able to prove out in the lab yet?
- Which types of test coverage do you currently have defined?
- Which tests are production-grade today and which remain conceptual or engineering-only?
- Do you have golden units, failure mode libraries, and pass/fail criteria documented for handover?
- Are there aspects of the design you believe will be difficult or impossible to test reliably on a production fixture?
ECOs, Change Loops, and Decision Friction (How Quickly Can We Change Direction?)
- How many ECO cycles feel like 'too many' for you — at what point does an ECO become a program risk?
- Describe your current ECO governance — who approves what, and how formal is the process?
- Typical turnaround time from ECO request to implemented change on the production line?
- Do you have a frozen-BOM milestone and how often has it slipped historically?
- How would you like joint ECO triage to work between our team and yours (cadence and tools)?
Escalations, Leadership & Risk Appetite (Who’s in the Room When Things Go Off-Script?)
- If a pilot issue threatens launch, who will be in the escalation loop and how fast will they act?
- How does your organization trade off schedule versus cost when making emergency decisions?
- Who has final go/no-go authority at pilot completion and at production release?
- What lessons from past escalations should we be aware of so we avoid repeating them?
- Would you be prepared to authorize an immediate stop-build if pilot yields or quality fall below agreed thresholds?
If We Could Wave a Wand (The One Guarantee That Lets You Sleep)
- If you could have one guarantee from a contract manufacturer during ramp, what would it be (yield, delivery, responsiveness, cost, or something else)?
- What is the minimum pilot quantity you need to feel confident the process is repeatable?
- How long a pilot execution window do you consider necessary to validate acceptance criteria?
- What documentation package do you require at production handoff (work instructions, FAI, control plans, SPC data)?
- How do you want status and issues surfaced during pilot — dashboards, weekly reviews, hands-on war room?
Practical Next Steps and Decision Signals (What Will Make You Say Yes?)
- What would convince you to sign an NPI engagement with us within the next 30 days?
- Which deliverables must be explicitly included in our proposal for you to move forward?
- What budget authority or procurement process do we need to align with to get started?
- Who else must be looped into final procurement and technical approval (names or roles)?
- Are there any absolute deal-breakers or non-negotiable constraints we should know before we draft a statement of work?
- When would you like a proposed plan and estimate delivered?
-
Solution Experience
Walk through how our NPI process (DFM/DFT, BOM lock, pilot builds, test development) mitigates the customer’s specific ramp risks.
Experience Meetings
- Current State & Stakeholder Alignment
- Ramp Risk Quantification Workshop
- Solution Experience Walkthrough — NPI Process Mapped to Your Risks
- Technical Deep Dive — Test, Pilot Execution & ECO Governance
- Decision & Mutual Commit Workshop
- Deliver a test coverage matrix and pilot execution plan with sample sizes and acceptance criteria.
- Customer to provide any missing numeric inputs (historical yields, backorder costs, lead times).
- Schedule the Solution Experience Walkthrough with the prioritized risk list as the agenda driver.
- One‑Sentence Recap & Consequences
- Confirm that the proposed NPI activities directly mitigate each prioritized ramp risk.
- Demonstrate proof that the NPI approach produces measurable improvement vs current state.
- Obtain explicit validation from the customer that the mapped mitigations and acceptance signals match their expectations.
- Define the acceptance gates and who owns each gate for the pilot and handoff.
- Produce a tailored NPI plan that maps actions to each prioritized risk with timeline and owners.
- Share supporting case studies or pilot data that substantiate expected deltas for similar programs.
- Capture any customer objections or gaps raised during validation and revise the NPI plan accordingly.
- Test Strategy & Coverage Matrix
- Finalize the test coverage matrix that maps tests to failure modes.
- Agree pilot sample sizes, acceptance thresholds, and ECO iteration plan.
- Establish fixture and test program delivery timelines and owners.
- Define ECO governance and change-control triggers for pilot and ramp.
- Introductions & Objectives
- Test engineering to provide fixture build schedule and resource needs.
- Program leads to draft ECO governance document showing review cycles and escalation path.
- Recap Agreed Current State, Consequence & Future State
- Obtain mutual signoff on the NPI scope, acceptance gates, and timeline.
- Agree ECO governance, roles, and escalation for the program.
- Identify and clear any commercial or schedule blockers required to proceed to kickoff.
- Seller to issue draft SOW and milestone-based acceptance criteria within 2 business days.
- Customer to confirm commercial anchors or PO intent and raise any contract issues within 3 business days.
- Schedule formal program kickoff and pilot start dates upon mutual agreement of SOW and resources.
- Create and record a single one-sentence current-state statement.
- Surface and assign owners to the top 3 ramp risks.
- Obtain quantified or directionally estimated consequences for each risk.
- Confirm decision roles, launch date, and escalation path to enable rapid approvals.
- Document and circulate the agreed one-sentence current-state and top risk list.
- Customer to provide BOM, ECO history, recent yield/test data, and committed launch date within 3 business days.
- Assign owners for each identified risk and schedule the Risk Quantification Workshop.
- Review Inputs & Assumptions
- Produce quantified impact estimates (cost/time/quality) for top ramp risks.
- Agree on concrete measurement baselines and success metrics for the NPI program.
- Prioritize the risk list to focus the Solution Experience on high-impact mitigations.
- Create a risk register with quantified impacts and agreed metrics for each top risk.
- One‑Sentence Current State
- Scenario Breakdown
- Review NPI Scope & Deliverables
- Known Failure Modes Review
- Risk-by-Risk Mapping
- Top Ramp Risks Identification
- Quantify Impact
- Acceptance Gates & Metrics
- Pilot Build Plan & Statistical Sampling
- Proof & Expected Delta
- Agree Measurement & Success Metrics
- Tying Steps Back to the Problem
- Fixture / Tooling / SW Requirements & Lead Times
- Roles, Timeline & ECO Governance
- Consequence Statements
- ECO Governance & Change Control
- Forced Validation
- Decision Roles, Launch Date & Escalation
- Commercial Anchors & Commit
- Prioritize Mitigation Focus
- Agreement on Acceptance Signals
- Decision & Next Steps
-
Solution Scope
Define NPI deliverables, responsibilities, acceptance criteria, pilot quantities, timeline, and ECO governance.
Scope Configuration
- Lock down BOM and qualify alternate suppliers
- Execute ECOs to make design production-ready
- Develop production work instructions and control plan
- Design and build assembly jigs and fixtures
- Develop and deploy production test fixtures and programs
- Run pilot production builds with controlled lots
- Perform first-article inspection and dimensional reporting
- Establish serialization, traceability, and lot tracking
- Set PCB assembly process parameters and reflow profile
- Implement procurement for long-lead components and safety stock
- Deploy firmware programming and automated flashing stations
- Train production operators and transfer manufacturing documentation
- Implement ESD controls, kitting, and static-safe storage
- Install in-line inspection and automated quality checkpoints
Scope Questions
Lock down BOM and qualify alternate suppliers
- Do you require a formal BOM lock as part of the NPI scope?
- Which BOM elements must be locked (mechanical parts, PCB assembly, firmware, packaging)?
- Are there single-source or long-lead components that need alternate sourcing?
- List the top 10 critical components (part number, manufacturer, current lead time) or attach BOM excerpt.
- What supplier qualification level do you expect for alternates (approved vendor list, sample builds, PPAP/qualification run)?
- What is the target date to have the BOM locked and alternates qualified?
Execute ECOs to make design production-ready
- Do you anticipate design changes (ECOs) are required before pilot builds?
- Who owns ECO approval and sign-off on the customer side (role/title)?
- What turnaround time do you require for ECO implementation and verification?
- Are ECOs limited to documentation/assembly notes or do they include PCB layout and mechanical rework?
- List acceptance criteria for ECOs (e.g., electrical test pass rates, dimensional tolerances, functional test results).
- Do you require change history, ECO traceability, and rollback plans as deliverables?
Develop production work instructions and control plan
- Do you require step-by-step work instructions for each assembly/test operation?
- Which formats do you need the documentation in?
- What quality control checkpoints and sampling plans should be included in the control plan?
- Who will be the document approver(s) for final work instructions?
- What is the required lead time to finalize work instructions before pilot start?
- Are there regulatory or industry-specific requirements that must be reflected in the control plan (e.g., IPC, ISO, medical)?
Design and build assembly jigs and fixtures
- Are custom assembly jigs or fixtures required for any build steps?
- Provide expected quantities or cycles those fixtures must support (pilot qty and projected volume).
- Do fixtures require precision alignment, kinematic locators, or specialized materials (ESD-safe, chemical resistance)?
- What is the expected timeline to design, prototype, and qualify fixtures before pilot?
- Who will own fixture validation and maintenance after handoff (customer, CM, shared)?
- Are 3D CAD files, tolerances, and assembly drawings available for fixture design?
Develop and deploy production test fixtures and programs
- What types of tests must production fixtures support (functional, ICT, in-circuit, boundary-scan, environmental)?
- Do you have test specs, test vectors, and failure mode descriptions available?
- Are there time-per-unit or cycle-time targets for the test cell?
- Will test fixtures need to program firmware or calibrate devices during test?
- What pass/fail criteria and data logging requirements (test logs, serial number linkage) are required?
- Do you require on-site validation and tuning of test programs during pilot?
Run pilot production builds with controlled lots
- What is the planned pilot quantity and any lot segmentation (e.g., lots of 50 units)?
- What specific metrics must be collected during pilot (yield, MTBF estimates, test fail rates)?
- Do you require controlled material lots and serialized tracking for pilot units?
- What are the acceptance thresholds for pilot success (target yield, acceptable defect rate)?
- Who will be involved in pilot reviews and sign-off (roles/titles)?
- Is there a requirement for pilot units to be shipped to customers or retained for further testing?
Perform first-article inspection and dimensional reporting
- Do you require a formal first-article inspection (FAI) with dimensional reports?
- Which reference drawings or tolerances should be used for dimensional checks?
- How many units should be sampled for FAI and what reporting format is required?
- Do you need measurement data in digital formats (CSV/AS9102/3D scan outputs)?
- Are there critical-to-function dimensions or interfaces that require CPK/SPC tracking post-FAI?
- Who will approve the FAI results and what is the expected turnaround for rework and reinspection?
Establish serialization, traceability, and lot tracking
- Do you require unit-level serialization or lot-level tracking?
- Which data points must be linked to each serial/lot (BOM revision, test results, operator, date)?
- Do you have an existing traceability format or database to integrate with (ERP/MES)?
- Are there labeling or marking requirements (barcode, 2D code, human-readable) and any regulatory constraints?
- What retention period and export/reporting requirements exist for traceability records?
- Do you require real-time traceability and recalls support as part of the scope?
Set PCB assembly process parameters and reflow profile
- Are PCB gerbers, assembly drawings, and thermal profiles available?
- Do you require CM to perform reflow profiling and thermal validation?
- What process windows and IPC class requirements apply (IPC Class 2, 3, etc.)?
- Are there special materials (lead-free, conformal coating, high-temperature parts) affecting profile?
- What acceptance criteria for solder quality and assembly defects should be used (e.g., X-ray, IPC-A-610)?
- Do you require SPC collection of process parameters (tombstone temp, conveyor speed, peak temp)?
Implement procurement for long-lead components and safety stock
- Which components are considered long-lead and must be procured early?
- Do you want CM to manage purchase orders and safety stock on your behalf?
- What safety stock policy do you prefer (days of cover, % of monthly usage, fixed qty)?
- Are there sourcing restrictions or approved manufacturer/authorized distributor lists we must follow?
- What lead-time alerts or reorder thresholds should be configured for procurement?
- Do you require alternate part qualification and substitution rules documented in procurement scope?
-
Mutual Commit
Agree commercial terms, milestones, acceptance tests, change control, and supply commitments for the NPI program.
Agreement Modules
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Master Services Agreement (MSA)
- Commercial Terms & Pricing Schedule
- Purchase Order / Supply Agreement
- Payment Schedule & Milestone Payments
- Acceptance Test Plan (ATP) & Acceptance Criteria
- Change Control & ECO Governance
- Pilot Build Order & Pilot Acceptance
- Capacity Reservation & Supply Commitments
- Quality, Warranty & Remedies
- Escalation & Governance (Steering Committee)
- Intellectual Property, Tooling & Asset Ownership
- Performance & Delivery Remedies
- Data Security & Confidentiality Addendum
- Termination, Transition & Exit Plan
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, pilot execution, and production validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Confirm fixtures, test software, qualified suppliers, materials on hand, and owners for pilot execution.
Readiness Questions
Quick Check‑In: Who Are We Helping and When?
- Tell us in one sentence what product is entering pilot and the committed launch date you’re reporting to leadership.
- Who will be our primary day‑to‑day contact for pilot execution and one alternate if they’re unavailable?
- What is the target pilot quantity (units) and the expected cadence of builds during the pilot window?
- Which business stakeholders have a firm say in the launch date (e.g., Product, Ops, Sales, Customer) — list their roles.
- How would you describe your emotional state about this launch right now—confident, cautiously optimistic, stressed, or other?
Are We About to Trust a Guess with Your Launch?
- What single assumption about this product or process, if wrong, would derail the pilot most quickly?
- Which of these areas do you think contains the riskiest assumption right now?
- Has a Design of Experiments or process capability study been run for the most critical steps? If so, summarize key findings.
- Tell us about a previous ramp or pilot you ran that had unexpected outcomes—what surprised you and how long did recovery take?
- How flexible is your committed launch date if we discover a serious, fixable problem during pilot?
Do You Actually Have The Parts When We Need Them?
- If a critical long‑lead component were delayed 2–4 weeks, what impact would that have on the pilot schedule?
- Which components are single‑source, custom, or have limited alternate suppliers?
- For the top five critical parts, what is current on‑hand coverage measured in weeks?
- Do you have approved second‑source suppliers or qualified alternates for any constrained items?
- If we need to authorize expedited buys or airfreight, who has signoff authority and what budget is pre‑approved?
Can We Detect the Next Production Failure Before It Ships?
- Which failure modes from prototype testing are most likely to recur during pilot and why?
- Are production test fixtures and jigs built and validated, or are they still in design/procurement?
- Is the test software finalized, version controlled, and ready to run unattended cycles?
- What percentage of known failure modes are covered by existing tests (rough estimate)?
- Who will maintain fixtures and handle on‑site debugging during pilot—list names/roles and escalation contact.
Who’s Driving This Train If Things Go Off‑Road?
- If a pilot run exposes a recurring defect, who is the accountable owner for root cause and corrective action?
- Are escalation paths and decision authorities documented, including SLA for critical decisions (e.g., ECO approval, emergency buys)?
- Who has final authority to approve ECOs during pilot (role and backup)?
- What cadence and format do you want for production status updates during pilot (e.g., daily standup, dashboard, email)?
- If a cross‑functional dispute arises (e.g., test vs. design), what is the pre‑agreed arbitration path?
Is the Floor, Schedule, and Logistics Ready to Carry the Load?
- Is dedicated floor space and the required equipment reserved for pilot runs on the dates we’ve discussed?
- Have ESD, cleanroom, environmental, and safety requirements been reviewed and satisfied for pilot production?
- Are we expecting any planned shutdowns, holidays, or supplier blackouts during the pilot window?
- Who will handle inbound inspection, material staging, and kitting for pilot builds?
- Do you require controlled build windows for the customer or external auditors to witness pilot runs?
If This Starts to Go Sideways, What’s Our Safety Net?
- Which of these risks would you rank as highest likelihood × highest impact: design yield, parts, test gaps, supplier failure, or process capability?
- For the top two risks you selected, what immediate mitigations are in place or planned?
- What contingency inventory or safety stock level (in weeks or units) would you accept to de‑risk early production?
- What dollar or timeline buffer has leadership pre‑approved for addressing emergent ECOs or rework during pilot?
- If a supplier proves unfit during pilot, how quickly can you qualify an alternate and who triggers that process?
What Would Make You Breathe Easy After Pilot?
- Describe the specific, measurable acceptance criteria for pilot success (e.g., target yield %, first article pass rate, test coverage metrics).
- Which of these metrics are non‑negotiable for launch approval?
- Who will sign the pilot acceptance—name and role—and what evidence do they require (reports, raw data, FAI documentation)?
- How would you like pilot data delivered and visualized (raw CSV, dashboards, daily summary report, real‑time queries)?
- What are the top three immediate next actions you commit to this week to make pilot readiness real?
- Is there anything about your product, supply chain, or internal politics we haven’t asked that could materially affect pilot readiness?
-
Pilot Build & Validation
Execute pilot runs, collect yield and test data, iterate ECOs, and perform first article inspections to validate processes.
-
Production Handoff & Ramp
Lock work instructions, finalize QC/test programs, qualify supply for volume, and schedule controlled ramp to full rate.
-
-
Success
Confirm acceptance criteria are met, capture lessons learned, and maintain a shared channel for issues and continuous improvement.
Success Reviews
- Acceptance Criteria Review & Sign-off
- Lessons Learned & Continuous Improvement Workshop
- Post‑Pilot Support & Issue Escalation Handoff
- Supply & Capacity Confirmation
- Executive Close‑out & Transfer Review
Issues & Enhancements
- Lock and publish the approved supplier list and alternate sources with qualification evidence attached.
- Publish SLA document and escalation matrix in the shared channel and link to the issue template.
- Schedule the recurring triage cadence and circulate calendar invites with agendas.
- Supplier Qualification Status
- Verify suppliers and materials are qualified and able to meet the ramp forecast or document mitigations where not.
- Agree on safety stock levels, trigger points, and owner responsibilities for supply interruptions.
- Produce a supply risk register with owners and timelines for mitigation.
- One‑sentence Current State
- Create a material shortage mitigation plan for any parts below required levels and assign owners.
- Update forecast and capacity plan in the production scheduler to reflect agreed ramp milestones.
- One‑line Current State & Future State
- Secure executive-level go/no‑go decision for full production ramp or capture explicit conditional approvals.
- Ensure commercial and financial obligations are aligned with operational readiness and documented.
- Record any executive-level contingencies and assign accountability for delivering them.
- Document executive decision, conditions, and required approvals; circulate final close‑out package to stakeholders.
- If approved, trigger production ramp schedule and notify supply chain and operations to execute the transfer plan.
- If conditional, capture required deliverables and timelines and schedule a follow‑up decision review.
- Validate evidence shows acceptance criteria are satisfied or record explicit remediation plans for any gaps.
- Obtain formal stakeholder sign-off (engineering, quality, supply, commercial) for production ramp or conditional approval with deadlines.
- Ensure ownership and timelines are assigned for all remaining risks with clear escalation triggers.
- Publish signed acceptance certificate and attach supporting evidence to the shared project channel.
- Create and assign remediation tasks for each open gap with owner and due date in the project tracker.
- Notify production scheduling of planned ramp date and any conditional constraints agreed during sign-off.
- Recap of Pilot Outcomes
- Capture a prioritized list of process and product improvements tied to measurable outcomes.
- Assign owners, timelines, and metrics to ensure continuous improvement actions are executed and tracked.
- Create a lessons‑learned deliverable to be shared with both customer and supplier stakeholders.
- Publish lessons‑learned document with RCA, recommended fixes, owners, and KPIs to the shared channel.
- Add improvement tasks to the continuous improvement backlog and schedule quarterly reviews.
- Update NPI checklist and work instructions to incorporate accepted process changes.
- Shared Channel & Tooling Setup
- Put in place a single source of truth for issue reporting and status tracking accessible to both customer and manufacturer.
- Agree on SLAs and escalation owners to ensure predictable response to production issues.
- Establish an operational meeting cadence that balances rapid response with governance.
- Provision the agreed shared channel and invite required stakeholders with appropriate access rights.
- Acceptance Criteria Walkthrough
- Material Availability vs Ramp Forecast
- Key Metrics vs Acceptance
- Issue Triage & SLA Definitions
- Top Failure Modes & Root Cause Analysis
- Process Improvement Brainstorm
- Escalation Matrix & Owners
- Commercial & Contractual Items
- Consequence & Residual Risk Summary
- Alternate Sourcing & Risk Mitigation
- Gap Remediation Plan
- Capacity & Contingency Plan
- Go/No‑Go Decision and Conditions
- Action Roadmap & Metrics
- Recurring Operational Cadence
- Formal Sign‑off / Next Steps